by Nicholas Mander
|Sir Geoffrey Le Mesurier Mander (1882-1962)1 was a Midland industrialist, an art collector and impassioned parliamentarian, and the Liberal specialist on foreign policy between the Wars. From a nonconformist and radical background, he held a strong patrician sense of public service and philanthropy. As a politician he was a man of integrity, ahead of his time, who spoke up as an anti-Appeaser and a crusader for the League of Nations in the Thirties. He made a reputation as an oppositionist, for his determined use of parliamentary questions; a gadfly who never spared to wing into the attack whenever sloppy thinking and deceit threatened to obscure the issues of the day. He represented Wolverhampton East from May 1929 to the 1945 Labour landslide.|
The Mander family
Geoffrey Mander came from a strong liberal tradition. The Mander family were in the vanguard of the industrial revolution in the Midlands.2
|From 1773 they established in Wolverhampton a durable cluster of businesses as manufacturers of chemicals, gas, japanware and (mostly successfully) varnish, paint and printing ink. By 1815 they were varnish manufacturers by appointment to Queen Charlotte. By 1827 they already operated 'one of the largest chemical elaboratories in the kingdom', trading from China and the East Indies to the Americas. As the business prospered with the industrial revolution, the firm of Mander Brothers became established as the varnish kings of the Empire, and the family were given the means and leisure to become active and progressive philanthropists.|
In the early nineteenth century, they campaigned against the slave trade, lobbied for the reform of the criminal code, and set up a union mill to provide cheap flour and bread in the difficult aftermath of the Napoleonic wars. Four Manders at the same time were Town Commissioners in Georgian Wolverhampton. They pursued a 22-year chancery suit for the protection of non-conformist chapels and endowments, a test case which was heard by the lord chancellor Eldon and was to lead to an act of Parliament by 1844. In 1817, Charles Mander rode to London to petition the home secretary, Sidmouth, for the reprieve of two innocent soldiers condemned to death for stealing a shilling coin. It was a romantic incident which appealed to the imagination of contemporaries and became the inspiration of a forgotten Methodist novel by Samuel Warren.3 It led with the help of Samuel Romilly in Parliament (the Manders' first counsel in their litigation) to the repeal of the Blood Money Act (1818), 'one of the worst acts ever to disgrace the Statute Book'. The family founded chapels, fountains, free libraries and schools, and became progressive mayors, filling nearly every public office in the county. Geoffrey's younger brother, the Hollywood actor and novelist Miles Mander (who married an Indian princess), summarized the background writing 'to [his] son in confidence' (1934):
|The Manders have nobly vindicated themselves. At the time of writing, they have produced one baronet, one Member of Parliament, High Sheriffs, Deputy Lieutenants and several of the lesser municipal dignitaries such as Mayors, Magistrates and Councillors. In fact, we are quite obviously worthy people... Your Canadian great-grandfather was in the Ottawa Parliament, your grandfather, Theodore, was one of the most prominent Liberals of his day, your Uncle Geoffrey is at present a Liberal Member, and I am hoping to be in the House shortly myself.4|
|Geoffrey Mander was the eldest son of Theodore Mander (1853-1900), a Gladstonian Liberal and strict Congregationalist. Theodore married Flora Paint, a Canadian from Nova Scotia of Guernsey extraction (from whose forebears Geoffrey derived his second name, Le Mesurier), whose father was himself, as Miles states, MP for Richmond county in the Dominion Parliament in the 1880s. Theodore was a man of refined tastes and sympathies, a collection of whose diaries and letters was published in 1996 as A Very Private Heritage.5 He is remembered today as the builder of Wightwick Manor (1887-93), a half-timbered aesthetic house of exquisite craftsmanship and detailing, with outstanding William Morris furnishings and pre-Raphaelite collections.|
Theodore in own his day was known as a Liberal and philanthropist. As a young man, he was active in public life in the arts and education, as a governor of the Grammar School, of Tettenhall College and of Birmingham University (where he endowed a scholarship), a member of the Royal Commission of the British Section of the Paris Exhibition and one of the founding benefactors of Mansfield College, Oxford, which was the first nonconformist college in the University. He described Henry Fowler, first viscount Wolverhampton, as 'his political mentor', chairing his election committee. In June 1895, he was offered the Mid-Worcester seat in Parliament. William Woodings of The Midland Liberal Federation wrote to him: 'Your name would be well known and you have almost a local connection... The constituency is Liberal in tendency and is not difficult to work.' He was still committed to municipal affairs, and didn't live long enough to contest the seat. He was a successful mayor of Wolverhampton at the turn of the century, he was presented to Queen Victoria, and among many public figures he entertained at Wightwick were the Duke and Duchess of York and the Chinese ambassador. But he died in office a few months later, in 1901, following an operation on his kitchen table. He was aged just 47.
Geoffrey was 16, and still at Harrow at the time of his father's death. His mother Flora died soon after, in 1905, leaving him to assume the responsibilities of his father's estate early. He was a prickly, cross-grained youth, described by the paterfamilias, his father's cousin, the staunch Tory Sir Charles Tertius Mander, as 'an impossible young cub... It is time we brought him up with a round turn... he is very self opinionated, has no judgment or tact & is much too big for his boots, & has been ever since his father died.'
|He went up to Trinity, Cambridge, where he followed family tradition by reading Natural Sciences. At Cambridge, he soon continued in the mould of public service, now with a radical slant. He joined the Union and the University Liberal League, and 'a thing called the Cambridge University Association for promoting Social Settlements. I have not the remotest idea what it's about, but I hope it's not socialism'. He founded a dining and debating club called 'The Dabblers'. Stephen Ponder writes:|
Like most members of the family, he became a magistrate, in his case at the age of 24, and in due course Chairman of the Bench, serving for 50 years. By the time of the Kingswinford by-election in 1905, the press is describing him as 'a Liberal member of a distinguished local Conservative family'. He supported the Labour candidate for West Wolverhampton in the 1906 election against a family friend, Sir Alfred Hickman. He wrote later: 'My action caused great indignation in Conservative circles in the neighbourhood and I found myself cut in the hunting field by some of them.' His second wife Rosalie described how, like many radicals who refused to conform to the conventions of the 'County' pattern, he was looked upon askance by many families. This attitude only changed after the second world war, 'both because party bitterness in general had died out and because Geoffrey Mander's sincerity and his devotion to the causes in which he believed won respect all round':
He cut his teeth as a Liberal member of the Wolverhampton Borough Council (1911-20). He shocked the Councillors, showing a foretaste of later interests, when he proposed a minimum wage of 23s. for all municipal employees. He came out in favour of his cousin Gerald's campaign to save the Old Deanery, an historic landmark in Wolverhampton attributed to Christopher Wren. This initiative was frustrated by the onset of war and the building where Dickens is said to have stayed was demolished in 1921.
He was High Sheriff of Staffordshire in 1921. He again created a stir when he proposed a woman as his successor, Lady Joan Legge, daughter of Lord Dartmouth. The Privy Council wrote to her father to inquire whether she had the necessary property qualifications, and she was not appointed. But he did secure the selection of the first woman to serve on the grand jury, Mrs Kempthorne, the wife of the bishop of Lichfield.
He stood unsuccessfully as a Liberal candidate for the Midland constituencies of Leominster in 1920 and then Cannock and Stourbridge. In 1929 he finally realized his early ambition by entering Parliament as Liberal MP for East Wolverhampton, a seat which had been represented by Liberals continuously since the Reform Bill of 1832. It included only three wards of inner Wolverhampton itself (as opposed to eight in Wolverhampton West), with urban districts and a cluster of independent surrounding villages. It was an area where Mander Brothers was dominant, with factories in both Heath Town and Wednesfield, and many employees of his works among the voters.
He was active in the Liberal Party organisation from the early 1920s, as a member of the executive committee of the National Liberal Federation and a frequent speaker at party Assemblies. He made a reputation as a parliamentarian by his skilful use of 'awkward' Parliamentary Questions, cornering the government of the day with his determined invigilation. The journalist Percy Cater recorded his memories of
|His special interests in Parliament were industrial relations, on which he spoke with authority and sympathy as a manufacturer through the Depression, and foreign affairs. Geoffrey became the Liberal expert on international relations, peace and disarmament, between the wars and the most ardent defender of the League of Nations system of collective security; 'the most persistent speaker and questioner on foreign affairs in the 1930s and altogether a zealot for the League'.7|
|He was one of the first to foresee the consequences of not taking a firm stand against the Japanese invasion of Manchuria in 1931. Into a House of Commons debate mainly devoted to currency, commerce, industry and tariffs, typically he intruded Manchuria and put forward the League position:|
As war again threatened again in the Thirties, he was one of the first to speak out against the Dictators. He tabled a number of Bills. The International Economic Sanctions (Enabling) Bill of 17 May 1933 made him 'one of the first to call attention to the German danger publicly in Parliament and at the same time make definite proposals for dealing with it'; supporters included Sir Austen Chamberlain whose 'death in 1937 was a heavy blow to peace'. The Peace Bill of 23 May 1935 (and subsequently) incorporated machinery embodied in the Covenant of the League of Nations for the settlement of international disputes, and was supported by Harold Macmillan, P. Noel-Baker, Sir Richard Acland and Lovat Fraser, inter alia.
In the 1935 General Election his comfortable victory against the Labour and Conservative opposition bucked the trend when the Liberals won only two other urban seats where they faced competition from both the other parties. He became a vehement, articulate critic of Neville Chamberlain's policy of Appeasement, and his 'inability to see what was going on in the world'; he was an ally of Churchill, Eden and Sinclair, whose polemical jabs were a wake-up call against a deep-rooted national will to self-deception. He recalled that it would remain 'one of the regrets of my life that I did not make some sort of speech ... when Mr. Chamberlain announced his intention of flying to Munich... If the Debate had been kept up, the spell would have been broken... Others would have followed and the dangers inherent in what was happening would have been exposed.'
His polemic was set forth in his book, We were not all Wrong (1941), arguing that many people and parties foresaw the disaster to which errors of policy in dealing with 'the Nazi menace' in the 1930s would inevitably lead:
A generation later, his son, John Mander, a political journalist and cultural critic, described the origins of Appeasement. Ironically, he wrote, in its intellectual perspective it was largely the creation of liberals of nonconformist background like his father:
His internationalist politics brought him into contact with Haile Sellassie and he was active in protesting against the Italian invasion of Abyssinia. When Geoffrey spoke up in the House of Commons in support of sanctions against Italy, Mussolini fired off a personal diatribe against him in his paper, the Popolo d'Italia. In 1938, in a climate of international tension, il duce took reprisals against the Milan branch of 'Fratelli Mander' and asked customers to boycott their goods.
Geoffrey was far sighted in many of his peace campaigns. He was one of a handful of MPs who inveighed against Hitler's territorial ambitions in the Ukraine in 1935. As war broke out in 1939, he pleaded just as assiduously the Jewish cause, telling Parliament in July that Government immigration policy was leaving Jews with no escape from Germany 'other than by illegal immigration into Palestine'. In April 1941, he wrote in the Jewish Standard: 'The cause of the Jews throughout the world is the cause for which Great Britain and her allies are fighting'.
Thurso regretted the 'massacre' of so many 'able, experienced and popular' candidates as he.13 There was a rumour for a time of his being given a peerage, and the Press proposed he be gazetted with the equivocal title 'Lord Meander', in commemoration of his tireless crusades and pertinacious questions, seamless diatribes and string of private member's bills in the House.
The family company, Mander Brothers, was known between the wars as a model company. Geoffrey, as the eldest of his generation, was chairman, while his cousin, Charles Arthur (the second baronet), was managing director. Sir Charles was 'wet' as a Tory, active in local government and Midland affairs, and deeply interested in everything that touched the human side of industry. In Parliament Geoffrey had pushed through the Joint Industrial Councils and Work Councils Bills. Together they implemented typically progressive initiatives in industrial welfare, to foster peace in industry. These included a joint works' council providing a workable system of joint consultation (1920), a welfare club (1920), profit-sharing schemes for employees, holiday schemes, suggestion schemes (1925), works pensions (1928), a house magazine, staff pensions (1935), and a 'contributory co-partnership scheme' setting aside shares for employees, with provisions to pay for shares by instalments.
Most notably, Manders was the first company in the country to introduce the forty-hour week. The historic agreement, the first of its kind in Britain, was brokered and signed by Ernest Bevin, general secretary of the Transport and General Workers' Union, in September 1932. 'Bevin was very proud of signing that agreement', said Geoffrey later: 'He used often to refer to it when were both in the House of Commons.' The press wrote: 'In the history of industrial welfare, Manders may claim a high place', where welfare had been 'part and parcel of the outlook of Manders as employers almost since the company's foundation in '. Geoffrey was reported summarizing:
As an art patron Geoffrey's contributions to Wightwick Manor have been his most secure legacy. When his father died young, much at Wightwick was left undone. But the sequel has been fortunate, for Wightwick is the creation of two generations. Geoffrey's was a man of vision and ability whose own contribution was decisive, and shows evolving attitudes at work in the interpretation of the nineteenth century.
His taste was decisive in creating the ensemble we see today; improving and deepening the collections, but also the garden. One of his first acts was in 1910, when, still in his twenties, he was already commissioning Thomas Mawson to design the garden terrace on the south side of the house.
He married first in 1906, Florence Caverhill, a Canadian like his mother. His second marriage in 1930 was to Rosalie Glynn Grylls (1905-1988).16 She was an early female graduate of Oxford; elegant, intellectual and talented. Elizabeth Longford was one of the last to remember this exceptional 'Cornish' girl at Lady Margaret Hall reading Modern Greats, 'brown eyed, dark haired, with teeth really like pearls ... who went on from strength to strength'. She described her as amusing and amused, full of anecdotes, a vivacious speaker, quick thinking and always exquisitely dressed; she was also 'the last of the militant atheists'. Her husband, Frank, who took schools on the desk beside her, was taken by 'the exceptionally pretty young girl whose arrival was always heralded by the tap of elegant shoes'.
|Like Geoffrey, Rosalie also entered politics, as a prospective Liberal candidate for Reading, when the Party was enjoying a revival. She was nearly 20 years younger than he, of course, and was secretary to the Liberal MP, Edgar Granville. Before the time came for her to face the electors, she married him in the crypt of the House of Commons. She was eyed with suspicion as a bluestocking in the wider family. She soon became known to them, who tended to pious disapproval of divorce and remained wary of radical politics, as 'The Secretary'.|
Geoffrey and his family. Children Anthea and John are in the centre, and Rosalie his wife, the Victorian biographer, is on the right.
|Rosalie never lost her interest in progressive politics. However, she went on to pursue her literary interests as a highly-regarded biographer, lecturer and scholar, particularly of the Shelley/ Godwin circle and the 'Pre-Raphaeladies'. With her knowledge and encouragement, Geoffrey began in the 1930s to develop and extend the collections at Wightwick and they became pioneers and authorities in the overdue re-assessment of Victorian art. They were among the first collectors to take a serious interest in the art and literary manuscripts associated with this late Romantic flowering, coming to know the survivors and successors of the circle of artists, designers and writers themselves. Many of them now visited Wightwick, like May Morris in 1938, or contributed to the collection, like Helen Rossetti Angeli, daughter of W.M. Rossetti and Lucy Maddox Brown, enriching its associations. They fostered links with the romantic Utopian socialism preached by William Morris, and many of the radical politicians and thinkers of the day visited what became a Midland political fortress.|
In December 1937 the future of house and collection was finally secured when Geoffrey presented it to the National Trust, with an endowment of 20,000 Manders shares. He was encouraged by the Trevelyans ('of another Liberal and eccentric family', wrote Rosalie, who gave Wallington to the Trust shortly afterwards) and Professor W.G. Constable.17 Rosalie Mander wrote: 'He never regretted it, for he liked to think that the public should enjoy what had been his private property.'18 He delighted in showing visitors round the house, and insisted on keeping no quarters barred from public view; his dressing room and bathroom included.
Geoffrey had installed a squash court in 1928 and continued to play tennis there until just shortly before he died aged nearly eighty in 1962. Lord Longford (then Frank Pakenham) wrote in his Times obituary that he was an 'issue man':
|There was never a more selfless politician... Perhaps he should not be thought of as a politician at all, for all his love of the House of Commons and the political life. He was supremely a man of causes. Abyssinia, Czechoslovakia, anti-Fascism, Collective Security-he preached them indefatigably and inflexibly, though with unfailing good humour, and what he preached he practised. |
He was the most modest of men and would have disclaimed the slightest comparison with Lord Cecil; yet even Lord Cecil did not embody more completely the idealism of the League of Nations and all it stood for. His horror of the whole policy of appeasement culminating in Munich led him to harry the Government with an endless stream of questions in the House of Commons, to the irritation of his opponents and the admiration of his friends.
In all the developments leading up to the establishment of the United Nations and throughout the years that followed, his staunchness and energy in the struggle for peace never flagged. It was the greatest of pities that he was without a seat in either House during the post-war years. But whether in his own Midlands or in the national and international politics he continued to find ways of rendering service that counted.
|1.||The fullest account is a booklet life, prepared by his widow mainly for sale at Wightwick: R.G.G. Mander, Geoffrey le Mesurier Mander (1882-1962), Donor of the house, Oxford [n.d.]. He left an autobiographical fragment (1924-57), in the National Liberal Association archives at Bristol University Library (DM668).|
|2.||For an account, see Geoffrey Mander (ed.), The History of Mander Brothers  and the author's own Varnished Leaves: a biography of the Mander family of Wolverhampton, 2004 (with bibliography).|
|3.||Now and Then, 1848.|
|4.||Miles Mander, To my Son-in Confidence, Faber, 1934. Lionel ('Miles') and his brother Alan both married daughters of the Maharajah of Cooch Behar. (see Sunitee Devee, Maharani of Cooch Behar, The Autobiography of an Indian Princess, 1921, pp. 43, 203-4.)|
|5.||Patricia Pegg (ed.), A Very Private Heritage: The Family Papers of Samuel Theodore Mander of Wolverhampton, 1853-1900, Malvern: Images Publishing, 1996.|
|6.||Wightwick Manor, National Trust guide, 1993.|
|7.||R.A.C. Parker, Chamberlain and Appeasement, 1993, pp. 40, 52 and 54.|
|8.||259 HC Deb 5s, cols 1189, 45, 60, 201-2; Parker, pp. 40-1.|
|9.||Geoffrey Mander, We were not all Wrong, 1938, 1941, pp. 87-9.|
|10.||We were not all wrong, p. 118.|
|11.||John Mander, Our German Cousins, 1974, p. 247.|
|12.||Archibald Sinclair (1890-1970), first Viscount Thurso (1951).|
|13.||G.J. de Groot, Liberal Crusader: The Life of Sir Archibald Sinclair, 1993, p. 227.|
|14.||The answer, like a four-move chess problem, is that I am his first and second cousin, twice removed.|
|15.||The agreement is quoted verbatim in The History of Mander Brothers. See also Mander Brothers Ltd., An Account of the Internal Organisation of the Business of Mander Brothers, Ltd., Wolverhampton, In its relationship to the Employee (Approved by the Joint Works Committee), 1925, revised 1934, 1939, 24 p.|
|16.||See obituaries in The Times (4 Nov. 1988); The Daily Telegraph (in part by Elizabeth Longford, 4 Nov. 1988); and Martin Drury (National Trust Magazine, Summer 1989).|
|17.||Director of the Courtauld Institute, London, and Slade Professor of Fine Art at Cambridge. Another kindred spirit in the League of Nations, connected (distantly) by marriage through the Turnbull family, was Roger, ninth Lord Stamford; the tenth Earl presented Dunham Massey to the National Trust in 1976.|
|18.||The Country House Remembered, edited by M. Waterson, 1985.|
|19.||J. Orbach, Victorian Architecture in Britain, 1987, p. 440; Martin Drury, 'Address to the 1999 AGM', Historic House, Spring 2000, p. 13.|